Shiny logos are just that. Shiny. If you take the time and energy to create a timeless logo for yourself why add excess and ruin your mark.
You want to keep your logo for quite some time and it should not be recognized for how bright and lustrous it appears on your website. Good branding will keep your logo consistent throughout the life cycle of the design and will not be a fancy trend.
Do not risk the having your logo fall behind the times and keep it as close to the original as possible.